True Lasagna Taste Test – Which Would You Prefer?

Do you ever see those taste-test commercials on TV and think, that would be fun to do? I know I have! So, when I was contacted by Michael Angelo’s to run a lasagna taste test with my family I jumped at the chance.

We were given a gift card to go purchase three lasagnas; a Marie Calender’s Three Meat & Four Cheese Lasagna, a Michael Angelo’s Meat Lasagna, as well as a Stouffer’s Lasagna with Meat & Sauce!

The first thing I did was compare the ingredients and found that Michael Angelo’s first ingredient was tomatoes, salt and basil, where as the other two lasagna’s first ingredients were water and tomato paste. I also noticed that Michael Angelo’s had the least amount of sodium of the three and the most Vitamin A, C, and calcium.

I then went to work on the actual items we would need for the taste test. Since I didn’t want anyone to know which item was which, Little Man and I worked to create paddles and a letter system. A for Michael Angelo’s, B for Stouffer’s, and C for Marie Calender’s!

I removed each lasagna from its box to look them over. From first glance the Michael Angelo’s seemed to have the most sauce, the Stouffer’s seemed to have the most cheese, and the Marie Calendar’s seemed to have the most spices…

Each company offered very easy-to-follow directions on their boxes, so cooking was a breeze! The Stouffer’s took the longest to cook so I put that one in first, then the Marie Calender’s, and then the Michael Angelo’s took the least amount of time. All three seemed to cook up nicely in the exact amount of time written in the directions.

After the lasagna’s were finished I put them side by side to compare them to each other. Each smelled and looked just amazing.

I then put small pieces of each lasagna on each place and added an A, B, or C marker so that we could keep track!

The Michael Angelo’s and Marie Calendar’s lasagna seemed to stay together the best as he Stouffer’s seemed to be very runny.

Then the family dug in…

What we all found was:

A – Michael Angelo’s – seemed to have the most cheese – you could really taste the ricotta.

B – Stouffer’s – seemed to have the most sauce – you could barely taste any cheese or meat, just sauce. Everyone agreed that you could tell this was “store-bought!”

C – Marie Calendar’s – seemed to have the most meats – this is a three meat lasagna and you could really taste the sausage, but not so much beef

Hubby liked the Stouffer’s best – which wasn’t surprising because he sticks to what he knows and likes and he was raised on the Stouffer’s! He also tends to dislike cheese and really like “saucy” meals.

The kids and I really liked the Michael Angelo’s the best. We are ones who really like cheese and this lasagna was more cheesy than meaty, which is good for those of us who prefer our lasagna this way.

Mother-in-law liked the Stouffer’s best. She tends to not like ricotta as much, so she liked the blander taste of the Stouffer’s.

Father-in-law was the only one who liked the Marie Calendar’s lasagna. He liked the taste of the different meats.

Final Thoughts – MIL – liked the “B” Stouffer’s & I liked the “A” Michael Angelo’s


Final Thoughts – Hubby liked the “B” Stouffer’s & all three kids liked the “A” Michael Angelo’s

All in all, this was such a fun experience. From start to finish we made it a family event and really enjoyed “testing” our taste buds!

I would love to hear from YOU! Leave a comment below letting me know which Lasagna you think YOUR family would like the best!

*Disclaimer – All food was sponsored by Michael Angelo’s. All opinions are honest and our own!

Post a Comment to Facebook!


Powered by Facebook Comments

Loading Facebook Comments ...


  1. what an awesome family night idea this would be so very fun and who can beat lasagna

    please come over and see me at I would love it if you would please leave a comment letting me know you were there

  2. I buy the Safeway Select brand from Von’s. I like it much better than Stouffer’s and this week with Just for U e-coupons you can get the big party size for $6.85. That’s cheaper than trying to make it. They have several types of lasagna, I get the meat, they also have chicken enchiladas, orange chicken and others.

  3. What a fun taste test you all had. Thank you for being honest and letting us know why different people in your family liked the different lasagnas the best.

  4. I’m thinking that I’d also like the Michelangelo’s based on how you described them. I’m more about the cheese and ricotta and NOT about the meat. Everyone looks so serious as they’re tasting. That made me giggle!

  5. Looks like fun! So wish I could have lasagna! No cheese for me!

  6. OK that would hard for me to do they all look good!

  7. Pam
    Twitter: imperfectwomen

    What a creative way of doing this and involving your family! Love it. We are a Stouffer’s family. We have tried most of the different brands out there and always come back to this one. That doesn’t mean I won’t give other brands another shot. One thing I found with Stouffer’s is that you have to cook it without the foil for more than the recommended time at the end and you have to let it set for 10 mins or more. Then it will not run.

    I am willing to try the Michael Angelo’s and will buy that brand the next time we are having lasagna and let you know how we liked it.

    Thanks for the great review.

  8. I’d have to go with the Michale Angelo’s as well!

  9. Sofia
    Twitter: frompdxwithlove

    By looks I would have gone with Stouffers….but by description I would have gone with Michael Angelos! I love lasagna!!

  10. That is super cute and so much fun to read….I love your ingenuity on this taste test. I don’t like runny lasagna at all, so I’d have to go with A or C.

  11. that’s such a fun taste test!! How fun! It’s great to know about the different brands and what makes them so different. I’d love to try the Michael Angelo’s I’m interested to see how Ricotta would taste in lasagna.

  12. I love that you did a taste test. My family definitely prefers Michael Angelos!

  13. this italian girl would love to try that, lol

  14. This looks like so much fun. I LOVE lasagna.

By continuing to use the site, you agree to the use of cookies. more information

The cookie settings on this website are set to "allow cookies" to give you the best browsing experience possible. If you continue to use this website without changing your cookie settings or you click "Accept" below then you are consenting to this.